To Comfort The Afflicted
And Afflict The Comfortable

To Comfort The Afflicted And Afflict The Comfortable

Monday, July 22, 2024


Keystone XL Not In National Interest



Here is information for readers who would like to help protect Oklahoma’s farmland and fragile aquifers.

TransCanada, a foreign corporation which has been bullying Oklahoma landowners, proposes to construct a 1700-mile pipeline, the Keystone XL, to carry raw Tar Sands crude, the world’s dirtiest crude, across the Midwest and from Cushing, OK, to Texas Gulf Coast refineries. The KXL would be an extension of the Keystone pipeline, put into operation in 2010.

There have already been 14 leaks from the Keystone pipeline. Can we expect better from the “KXL,” which would operate under similar conditions? There are no U.S. federal safeguards in place for the safe transport of Tar Sands crude. It is asphalt-like DilBit – toxic and corrosive and presenting special challenges for cleanup.

Natural gas in Tar Sands pipelines makes them vulnerable to explosions. An explosion in a Michigan pipeline sent Tar Sands crude into the Kalamazoo River and eventually into Lake Michigan. A year later the spill had not been cleaned up.

Will the KXL actually contribute net energy? The pumping requires enormous amounts of electricity which would probably be supplied in Oklahoma by coal. The Keystone pipeline has become the largest user of electricity in the state of Kansas.

Who will get the KXL oil, once it has been refined in Texas and has contributed to horrible air pollution there? Research indicates the oil is not destined for the U.S. market but will indeed affect us by causing a rise in gasoline prices here. [A TransCanada spokesman testified to the Canadian National Energy Board that part of the purpose of the Keystone XL is to raise the price of heavy crude oil in the Midwest!] Multi-national oil companies will reap the profits.

Supporters of the KXL are putting their hope in TransCanada’s promise of many jobs. However, the U.S. State Department says most of the jobs will be non-local and temporary.

What won’t be temporary? If contamination occurs in an aquifer [the Ogallala Aquifer, for example, is threatened] it cannot be undone. How many livelihoods – of farmers, ranchers, tourism personnel – will be disrupted? Wouldn’t this be devastating to our heartland agriculture?

Extraction of Tar Sands crude – strip-mined in the pristine Canadian Boreal forest [and projected to denude an area the size of Florida] – has been called the most destructive project on the planet and is a major source of carbon pollution in the northern hemisphere. Enormous amounts of water are used and leaks from waste ponds have caused soaring cancer rates among indigenous people. A staggering number of migratory birds are losing their habitat.

The KXL Pipeline is not in our national interest. There is unprecedented public opposition to this pipeline. Opposing groups include the National Farmers Union, Transport Workers Union, National Congress of American Indians, mayors, scientists, Nobel Peace Laureates and every major environmental organization in the U.S.

The pipeline cannot be built without permission from President Obama. Citizens have the opportunity to make official comments to the U.S. State Department.

To make oral comment in person, citizens may attend the Oklahoma public hearing on Sept. 30, at the Reed Center Exhibition Hall, 5800 Will Rogers Rd., Midwest City, OK. Comments of three to five minutes will be heard from 4:30 to 10:00 pm, in first-come, first-served order.

For written comments to the State Department, here are the:

Online at

By e-mail at

By FAX at 206-269–0098

By mail to

Alexander Yuan

Keystone XL EIS Project

P.O. Box 96503-98500

Washington, D.C. 20090-6503

Deadline for comments to be submitted is midnight October 9, 2011.

There is ample information online about the Keystone XL Pipeline. Two suggested websites are and

The author lives in Tulsa


Previous article
Next article


    • Don’t you think we should consider the cost to our livelihood and damage to properties when permitting pipelines such as this into our land? What affects the land and water and the health of the people must be considered. Let us not enter into this blindly.

  1. This pipeline is NOT owned by the United States of America……Does that not make anyone wonder why foreign governments are using our country to make their greedy profits. If the U.S. thinks it’s a good deal, why isn’t some American company contracting with the American land owners for the easement rights for this pipeline? Who will be cleaning up the spills? There are going to be spills. One of TransCan’s pipelines has already pollutted the Kalamazoo River and into one of the Great Lakes from a recent spill. It has yet to be cleaned up. Will it be a situation like the lead chat piles left behind for Oklahoma taxpayers and some Federal funds to pay to clean up when the coal ran out ??? Taking the profits and clearing out when they end is almost a given when you allow outsiders to come into your home, mine all the goodies and leave all the messes. Do we have to keep learning these lessons over and over? They all lie about it and here we go again….learning too late on another scam. Say NO TO KEYSTONE XL!!!

Arnold Hamilton
Arnold Hamilton
Arnold Hamilton became editor of The Observer in September 2006. Previously, he served nearly two decades as the Dallas Morning News’ Oklahoma Bureau chief. He also covered government and politics for the San Jose Mercury News, the Dallas Times Herald, the Tulsa Tribune and the Oklahoma Journal.