To Comfort The Afflicted
And Afflict The Comfortable

To Comfort The Afflicted And Afflict The Comfortable

Tuesday, January 19, 2021


Worrying About Israel



Am I concerned, friends ask me quietly, after we all publicly praise President Obama’s monumental Cairo speech. The friends are usually, but not always, Jewish. They are all, like me, strong supporters of the state of Israel.

The answer is that of course I’m concerned. I’m very concerned. But since when has a supporter of the state of Israel not been concerned?

These are, nonetheless, especially sensitive and worrisome times, not only because of Iran’s bellicose threats, continued Palestinian attacks and, yes, Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s aggressive stance, but also because many of us aren’t completely certain we know where this president will stand in a crisis.

I’m not pretending it’s easy. I can’t defend Netanyahu’s decision to continue to expand existing settlements on disputed lands at this point in time. To be honest, I can’t even defend my own behavior when I happen upon two lines at the TSA checkpoint, as I did a few weeks ago at Dulles International Airport, and go out of my way to choose the line with four businessmen ahead of me, instead of the nonexistent line behind a Muslim family trying to take apart their stroller. As I cruise through security, I look back to see TSA officials taking the dirty diapers out of the diaper bag. Are they wrong? No, of course not. Ninety-nine percent of Muslims are not terrorists, but in our experience, nearly 100% of the terrorists who have attacked us are Muslim.

That is why Obama’s message of respect for Islam is so important. It is better, far better, for the Muslim world to hate us a little less than they did, even if that is all the president accomplished. And there is reason to hope he accomplished far more. It is critical to create an environment in which the moderate Muslims we hear too little from feel free to speak out, and hopefully the president’s speech is a step in that direction. A speech like that is one none of us – Muslim, Christian or Jew – has heard in a long time, and it is critically important that we do.

Moreover, Obama sensitively combined his speech in Cairo with a visit to the Nazi death camp at Buchenwald. It was a visit the president said he would remember for the rest of his life, and I have no doubt that is so. The brutality of Nazi anti-Semitism ultimately forced most of the world to recognize the right to a Jewish state. In that way, it has been as powerful a force as the Israeli Air Force in Israel’s security, which is why it is so important to Iran to deny its existence.

But it is not enough. The events surrounding the liberation of Buchenwald 64 years ago, powerful as they should always be, are not enough to provide a pillar for Israel for the next 64 years. A visit to Buchenwald is not enough to secure Israel’s future. That is why, as always, I am worried.

Obama has stepped up to incredible challenges with a sense of confidence and a keenness of intelligence that no one, frankly, has a basis to expect of any president on his first day. I am proud that he is our president. But that doesn’t mean he is incapable of making a mistake. It doesn’t mean he should be freed from the influence of his friends.
Trust but verify, as another president so famously said – a motto that applies to both friends and enemies. For those of us who are strong supporters of the state of Israel, there has never been a more important time to make our voices heard.

Susan Estrich’s columns appear regularly in The Oklahoma Observer

Creators Syndicate

Arnold Hamilton
Arnold Hamilton
Arnold Hamilton became editor of The Observer in September 2006. Previously, he served nearly two decades as the Dallas Morning News’ Oklahoma Bureau chief. He also covered government and politics for the San Jose Mercury News, the Dallas Times Herald, the Tulsa Tribune and the Oklahoma Journal.